League 1 (Apr 2025)

8 categories · 72 submissions

I’ve got a big decision to makeApocalypseHot Girl SummerAwake at 3 amLonging for a placeBrutal BreakupHangar Porch SitSouth Bend Idol
SongArtistCategorySubmitted byVotes
swan songVictoria CanalAwake at 3 amfionmul
10
Dare You to MoveSwitchfootI’ve got a big decision to makefionmul
9

fionmul: a throwback… 63 million streams for a reason

Far from MeJohn PrineBrutal BreakupSamRobertsND
9
This Is the EndThe Ghost of Paul RevereApocalypseared56
8
Is It a CrimeSadeAwake at 3 am[DELETED]
8
A Little Bit of EverythingDawesLonging for a placeSamRobertsND
8
  • Edward James +2I feel like I’ve heard this before….but in the initial verse I wanted to hate it…..and then it got me good. I have been had, and for that, 2 votes. It do be like that.
  • judd.baker +2Existential banger
  • shea nowicki +2
  • [DELETED] +1
  • ared56 +1
  • fionmul 0samuel l roberts SJPhD? I like the Lizzy one better though
  • Joseph Harvey 0Chicken wing as a lyric is an instant turn off
MediocreXimena SariñanaBrutal Breakupjudd.baker
8

judd.baker: just look up the words

ChangesLanghorne Slim, The LawHangar Porch SitRegina Scime
8

Regina Scime: “there’s many reasons we are what we’ve become… I’m going through changes now”

BelieveBrooks & DunnHangar Porch SitEdward James
8

Edward James: A throwback to “sad country porch sits” in early Hangar days. Maybe not what was meant, but this song for me will forever be sitting on the porch rocking chair watching the sunset

Live Like You Were DyingTim McGrawSouth Bend IdolSamRobertsND
8

SamRobertsND: The climax of any great bar karaoke night. In Miller Lite fueled joy, the whole place is belting out the last refrain together. No other song comes close for me in fun and finality.

  • Joseph Harvey +2I can see George singing this. Also the prechorus is Sting-y
  • ared56 +2
  • Edward James +2As Helen demonstrated, aligning song choice with the vibe can propel a great performance to an electric one. This would have me weeping (as it typically does). Debated giving but 3 votes until I learned I can’t
  • Regina Scime +1
  • judd.baker +1
  • fionmul 0I know what you mean! I just think there is a huge difference between bar karaoke and south bend idol
My LifeBilly JoelI’ve got a big decision to makeRegina Scime
7
Under Pressure - Remastered 2011Queen, David BowieI’ve got a big decision to makeSamRobertsND
7
A Hard Rain's A-Gonna FallBob DylanApocalypseEdward James
7

Edward James: Written under the ever-present threat of nuclear annihilation around the Cuban missile crisis

The Dead Flag BluesGodspeed You! Black EmperorApocalypse[DELETED]
7
Summertime Sadness (Lana Del Rey Vs. Cedric Gervais) - Cedric Gervais RemixLana Del Rey, Cedric GervaisHot Girl Summerfionmul
7
I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking ForU2Longing for a placefionmul
7
SailingChristopher CrossLonging for a place[DELETED]
7
Idiot WindBob DylanBrutal BreakupEdward James
7

Edward James: Imo no song put the “brutal” in brutal breakup better. The slow shift from focusing on other to self 👌

Don't You Worry 'Bout A ThingTori KellySouth Bend IdolRegina Scime
7
  • fionmul +2Okay yeah. If someone nailed this we give them the crown and cancel the event in the future.
  • Joseph Harvey +2Wow! I would be swaying in my seat to this for sure
  • SamRobertsND +1
  • Edward James +1Glad I checked again on the screen here because it transferred the wrong version to Apple Music and this one is better.
  • shea nowicki +1
Dies IraeGiuseppe Verdi, Carmen Giannattasio, Veronica Simeoni, Alxander Timchenko, Carlo Colombara, Yuri Temirkanov, St. Petersburg Philharmonic OrchestraApocalypseSamRobertsND
6

SamRobertsND: “ And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him.”

EspressoSabrina CarpenterHot Girl SummerJoseph Harvey
6

Joseph Harvey: I’m afraid to read the lyrics but dang, what a banger

crazy for youMarina SaitoHot Girl SummerEdward James
6

Edward James: May summer find us all this way

Dancing QueenABBAHot Girl SummerRegina Scime
6
Never Gonna Be Alone (feat. Lizzy McAlpine & John Mayer)Jacob Collier, Lizzy McAlpine, John MayerAwake at 3 amJoseph Harvey
6
One Last BreathCreedAwake at 3 amSamRobertsND
6
Midnight CityM83Awake at 3 amEdward James
6

Edward James: The feeling of being alive late at night

Carrickfergus (Arr. Pacey)Traditional, VOCES8, SibéalLonging for a placeJoseph Harvey
6

Joseph Harvey: I have shed tears to this song on multiple occasions

good 4 uOlivia RodrigoBrutal Breakupshea nowicki
6

shea nowicki: We have to pray for Olivia.... I'm worried about her

  • Joseph Harvey +2Not bad for being 16 or whatever
  • fionmul +1dude yeah it’s diagnosable. Also this song is really so good, appreciated it a lot musically in this listen.
  • Edward James +1Straight banger that somehow still gets how it really be
  • SamRobertsND +1
  • Regina Scime +1
SurefireWilderadoHangar Porch Sitshea nowicki
6
Put Your Head On My ShoulderPaul AnkaSouth Bend Idolfionmul
6
The ClimbMiley CyrusSouth Bend IdolEdward James
6

Edward James: I know you feel it

Do You Wanna Do Nothing with Me?LawrenceI’ve got a big decision to makeEdward James
5
California GurlsKaty Perry, Snoop DoggHot Girl SummerSamRobertsND
5

SamRobertsND: You have to understand how rebellious singing “bikinis on top” made a sheltered teenager feel

Close To YouGracie AbramsHot Girl Summershea nowicki
5
26CaampLonging for a placeshea nowicki
5
  • Regina Scime +2
  • ared56 +2
  • fionmul +1:) Shea ily let’s move to alaska. i’ll be 26 in august
  • Joseph Harvey 0Shea
  • Edward James 0Good song but I can’t stand the way this guy sings despite liking some of their songs
  • judd.baker 0I’ve heard exactly one other Caamp song but they have a high batting average
Blood Sport - from the room belowSleep TokenBrutal BreakupJoseph Harvey
5

Joseph Harvey: Stuck in a quantum pattern

Daylight FadingCounting CrowsHangar Porch Sitjudd.baker
5

judd.baker: Moonlight creeping round the corners of our lawn

The Stable SongGregory Alan IsakovHangar Porch Sitfionmul
5
WhiskeyTrampled by TurtlesHangar Porch Sitared56
5
  • shea nowicki +110/10 listening experience
  • SamRobertsND +1The old country
  • fionmul +1Yes. Just the first few seconds and I am in. I had moonshine for the first time on this porch. And also on this hallowed porch, realized I like whiskey and its buzz for better or worse.
  • Edward James +1
  • judd.baker +1
I Heard a RumourBananaramaI’ve got a big decision to make[DELETED]
4
Benny HillTV ThemesI’ve got a big decision to makeared56
4
Turn your Eyes Upon JesusJosh GarrelsI’ve got a big decision to makeshea nowicki
4
ZombieThe CranberriesApocalypsefionmul
4
It Would Be YouBen RectorApocalypseRegina Scime
4

Regina Scime: why not dance through the end times?

Evacuate The Dancefloor - Radio EditCascadaHot Girl Summer[DELETED]
4
AphasiaPinegroveAwake at 3 amjudd.baker
4

judd.baker: soundtrack to my parents divorce

The Old ApartmentBarenaked LadiesLonging for a placeared56
4
2016 CAVALIERS (Ohio) (feat. Knox)Knox, BilmuriHangar Porch SitJoseph Harvey
4
Ain't That A Kick In The HeadDean MartinSouth Bend Idoljudd.baker
4
HypocrisyJoseph HarveySouth Bend IdolJoseph Harvey
4

Joseph Harvey: Sorry, this is obnoxious

BaltimoreThe BellfuriesSouth Bend Idol[DELETED]
4
Lost in My MindThe Head And The HeartI’ve got a big decision to makejudd.baker
3

judd.baker: Lost in your mind when you’re trying to make a big decision, and sometimes you need someone else to help pull you out of that place

  • ared56 +2
  • shea nowicki +1love the head and the heart-- exact who I want to counsel me in my decision making!!!
  • fionmul 0Eh
BearerHumanity's Last BreathApocalypseJoseph Harvey
3

Joseph Harvey: In the running for heaviest song of all time I think. The end feels like you’re being progressively slammed further and further into the center of the earth

Everybody Wants To Rule The WorldTears For FearsApocalypseshea nowicki
3
We Will Become Silhouettes - RemasteredThe ShinsApocalypsejudd.baker
3

judd.baker: It’s literally the apocalypse

Everytime We TouchCascadaHot Girl Summerared56
3
GrapevineWeyes BloodHot Girl Summerjudd.baker
3

judd.baker: Ghost of hot girl summers past

Brian WilsonBarenaked LadiesAwake at 3 amared56
3
  • judd.baker +2This is so f in good
  • Edward James +1Imitation is the highest form of flattery. Something very real about imitating others at 3am as your ponder
  • Joseph Harvey 0This song was engineered in a lab to be optimally irritating
  • Regina Scime 0I have so many questions
  • fionmul 0"Who is Brian Wilson." - Joseph
ChicagoSufjan StevensLonging for a placejudd.baker
3

judd.baker: I’m told there have been popes from here

  • Joseph Harvey +2Incredible song and bang on for theme and current moment
  • shea nowicki +1
  • fionmul 0edward? i totally thought this was gonna be the one you hear a lot on reels i’m dumb for that
  • Edward James 0I feel dirty not voting for this, but I have to be true to my heart for this round and others compelled me more at this particular moment
Precious Lord (Arr. for Choir by Arnold Sevier)Thomas Dorsey, National Youth Choir Of Great Britain, Lisa GrahamLonging for a placeRegina Scime
3

Regina Scime: take my hand, precious Lord, lead me home

SuffocateColdBrutal Breakup[DELETED]
3
  • judd.baker +2This round was so strong but I just think this is doing the best job of being truly “brutal.” Like a brutal breakup isn’t just sad, you’re infuriated
  • ared56 +1
  • fionmul 0post 9/11 type singing. Actually though I am sorry to the men in this league who were hurt by women in brutal ways 🫂
Unkiss MeMaroon 5Brutal Breakupfionmul
3

fionmul: 💔

  • judd.baker +1I was surprised by this song, musically it’s not my thing and I was almost deceived by it not sounding brutal enough but the lyrics are perfect. Someone needs to cover this song as an emo song
  • [DELETED] +1
  • shea nowicki +1
  • fionmul 0the words just really get at it for me 😩
Thanks That Was FunBarenaked LadiesBrutal Breakupared56
3
I Want You BackThe Jackson 5South Bend Idolshea nowicki
3

shea nowicki: I picked this because it is "phlegmatic oomph"

Battle Hymn Of The RepublicJudy GarlandSouth Bend Idolared56
3
  • Edward James +1Had to give a vote because if someone did this at SB Idol I would have lost my mind
  • shea nowicki +1
  • [DELETED] +1
  • fionmul 0this would be a power move for a last song indeed #AmericanPope
  • Joseph Harvey 0Could be an interesting first round, don’t know about third
Suspended In This DisasterDance Gavin DanceI’ve got a big decision to makeJoseph Harvey
2

Joseph Harvey: If you make it through the bit of screaming at the beginning, chorus is a bop

Covers YouFuture Of ForestryAwake at 3 amRegina Scime
2

Regina Scime: ambient but epic orchestra, comforting words

  • SamRobertsND +1
  • fionmul +1<3 Makes me wanna ride a horse in a meadow at twilight
  • Joseph Harvey 0INCREDIBLE intro and verse tragically let down by a very weak chorus
Expert In A Dying FieldThe BethsLonging for a placeEdward James
2

Edward James: I can close the door on us, but the room still exists

  • Joseph Harvey +1I think about this every day as a manual driver. Also minor iv chord gets me every time
  • shea nowicki +1
  • fionmul 0Judd? this reminds me of the movie 500 days of summer cuz the beths
ザ・ワード IISHIGEO SEKITOHangar Porch SitSamRobertsND
2
STUCKSam GellaitryHangar Porch Sit[DELETED]
2
You're Gonna Be Okay (feat. VOCES8)Cody Fry, VOCES8Brutal BreakupRegina Scime
1

Regina Scime: “not the place that I thought I’d be losing it all”

  • SamRobertsND +1This is what you could be, Joseph
  • fionmul 0this almost seems too deep for a breakup but maybe if someone left me at the altar sorta deal. but i appreciate the beautiful sound like light shining through the cloud of Lord whyyy
  • Joseph Harvey 0Too nice sounding
Imagine - Remastered 2010John LennonAwake at 3 amshea nowicki
0