Billy Joel

5 submissions

SongCategoryLeagueSubmitted byVotes
And So It GoesBindlecoreLeague 9 (Apr 2026)Brad Stalcup
5
  • SamRobertsND +1Understood the assignment, as the kids say.
  • Peter Seeley +1Don't know if this fits the theme, but it's the best song on the list
  • Claire +1I like this pull a lot. Never would’ve thought of it for this round but I think it’s an earnest portrayal of the sort of emotion that the bindle captures in a more comical way
  • shea nowicki +1
  • Regina Scime +1I don’t know what it is about this song, but it makes me so emotional
  • Edward James 0I think we’re gonna have a lot of people who interpreted this category very differently. But whatever this is, it doesn’t fit in my interpretation at all.
  • fionmul 0This was really close for me but I tried to see past the sentimental familiarity with the sound and found others to be stronger
  • Brad Stalcup 0This is Billy Joel's favorite song that he wrote
  • judd.baker 0Great song, but this is too noble to be bindle.
My LifeI’ve got a big decision to makeLeague 1 (Apr 2025)Regina Scime
7
Turn the Lights Back OnLate career bangersLeague 9 (Apr 2026)shea nowicki
6
  • fionmul +1Love William. I think about his and Gordon’s talent show in Indianapolis often.
  • SamRobertsND +1
  • Edward James +1This was wonderful. I expected it to be from the early 2000s and was surprised to see it was 2024. Perfect choice.
  • Sam Ary +1
  • Regina Scime +1
  • Claire +1Billy ily. Maybe I’m biased bc i have seen him perform so late in his career and can confirm that he’s still got it
  • judd.baker +1Loved this. Billy Joel is a definitive example to me of a career with a couple noteworthy late hits.
  • Peter Seeley -1Weakest of the lot
ViennaDesert Island SongsLeague 2 (May 2025)Regina Scime
4
We Didn't Start the FireSummer GrillingLeague 3 (Jun 2025)Regina Scime
1
  • fionmul +1hard to miss here 😉
  • shea nowicki +1
  • SamRobertsND 0A fun one but not right for this. Props for not posting the terrible Fallout Boy version at least.
  • Edward James 0Too frantic. Grilling is a meditative, transcendent reality. That doesn’t mean it’s slow, but it’s also not hectic.
  • Claire 0It’s giving “dad” but not “grilling” for me ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
  • judd.baker -1I just hate this song so much