IceJJFish

1 submission

Song	Category	League	Submitted by	Votes
Holy God	Songs Joseph Would Hate	League 7 (Dec 2025)	Sam Ary	8 Sam Ary: For your holy hour playlists Peter Seeley +2 — "I messed up ag-ay-ay-an" killed me Regina Scime +2 — Ok first of all, this sounds like something Sam would make for fun. Second, I need to listen to this whenever I’m feeling discouraged hahahahah shea nowicki +2 — Egregious. You nailed it. Claire +1 — “How did this not hurt Joseph?” “This has to be satire” -Fiona Brad Stalcup +1 — Would Joseph hate it? Yes. Would everyone else hate it? Yes. Would God himself hate it? I'm leaning towards yes. Spicey Riche +1 Joseph Harvey 0 — Hating this song would feel mean. Also can’t hate anything with this much ambient guitar fionmul 0 — “This is going to wreck my Spotify algorithm for the rest of the year” - Claire judd.baker 0 — Something about this song itself actually feels inspired. For being a genuinely creative song with (probably intentionally?) imperfect vocals, however, it’s not really an inspired choice for this round. Joseph would probably dislike the vocals, sure, but that feels too obvious to me. ared56 -1 — I refuse to believe that anyone listens to this earnestly or for comedic value.