Claire+1 — Thought about submitting this one. American Idol in the aughts was such a beautiful cultural moment
fionmul0 — This needed to be here; thank you. My vote got stolen from this song by things that were a bit less obvious/flat. Honestly, playlist order effects my voting a lot more than I would have thought.
Joseph Harvey0 — One bad day does not an “it’s so over” make. With that said this is an extremely well written song which I never realized before, so thank you
SamRobertsND0 — What is this, 2006? Get this American Idol shit out of here
Edward James0 — I’m sorry, but this song will never be anything but funny to me. I was giggling throughout. You can even ask Alex.
Brad Stalcup0 — I can't help but think of American Idol when I hear this song.
judd.baker-1 — My criteria for this round is that to be truly a song about failure and despair, there’s gotta be no silver lining. This song has too much residual hope, as though too far along in the stages of grief. A little too upbeat, therapeutic, forward-looking