The Irish Rovers

2 submissions

SongCategoryLeagueSubmitted byVotes
Finnegan's WakeAccidentally Flannery O’ConnorLeague 4 (Jul 2025)Brad Stalcup
-2
  • ared56 +1
  • Brad Stalcup 0 — The Whiskey washing over Tim can definitely be seen as a symbol of baptism, which takes place in the midst of the fury and warring of man. "The uncontrollable mystery on the bestial floor" (Yeats)
  • Joseph Harvey 0 — No
  • shea nowicki 0 — This surprised me. At first, I dead set against it— “no way” does Flannery give me Irish vibes. In the end, maybe I came around!!
  • Regina Scime 0 — Fiona-coded
  • fionmul 0 — I love Irish music but it’s not Flannery enough for that reason regardless of lyrics. A ton of Irish songs are Flannery vibes if you overlook the Irishness (but I don’t).
  • Edward James -1 — This is a straight banger but don't see the fit at all. Not through vibe, narrative, or themes.
  • judd.baker -1 — Accidentally James Joyce
  • Claire -1 — It’s a classic but it just doesn’t work for the theme imo. Sure, a dead man comes back to life, but in a gimmicky magical drinking song way
The Black Velvet BandFemme FataleLeague 2 (May 2025)ared56
1
  • fionmul +1 — Irish femme fatale, a fresh take and I liked it. You got my last vote.
  • Claire +1 — She was the blueprint
  • Edward James 0 — Very good and on theme but just got beat out by others
  • SamRobertsND 0 — Wholesome but I want to hear the woman, not the dumb simps
  • Sam Ary -1