John Mayer

2 submissions

SongCategoryLeagueSubmitted byVotes
CrossroadsAccidentally Flannery O’ConnorLeague 4 (Jul 2025)Laur
2

Laur: Yes, I do believe she wears aviators and drives a very old car down the road when she’s listens to this one

  • Regina Scime +1
  • Corey +1
  • Sam Ary +1
  • Edward James 0I really like this pick, the idea of being at a crossroads but unsure what to do is a good theme. But I think it needs to develop beyond that, and the song just doesn't go any further. Totally fine, but that keeps it off the podium for me.
  • Joseph Harvey 0Eh. Just not enough substance here when there are so many great picks.
  • judd.baker 0I didn’t know John Mayer did this kind of sound tbh
  • fionmul 0Unmemorable
  • Claire 0Love John Mayer but there’s not enough lyrically here for me to really judge how well it fits the, for better or worse, quite literary theme
  • ared56 -1
In Your Atmosphere - Live at the Nokia Theatre, Los Angeles, CA - December 2007Live, Laugh, LIVELeague 3 (Jun 2025)Sam Ary
0

Sam Ary: One of the best live performances

  • Claire +1I almost submitted this song. It’s a beautiful song in itself and I think John Mayer really shines as a musician in a live setting. If I remember correctly, the lore about this song is that he never released a studio version because he said it would just never measure up to the way the song sounds and feels live. I think he’s probably right.
  • SamRobertsND 0I liked this, but it was just a little unmemorable because it's not really my taste. Reminds me of the theme song to an early 2000s CW show.
  • fionmul 0I loved this, esp the vocals at the end and I am not sure I had heard this song before. I also considered John.
  • Edward James 0Despite my priors, I actually really like John Mayer. This was great, but I don’t see how it’s particularly spectacular beyond his usual stuff.
  • Joseph Harvey 0I mean this is cool but Neon is on this album and that’s a way more impressive live performance to me. That’s an insane song on guitar, and the fact he sings while playing at that level is incredible. That song would have gotten my vote
  • judd.baker 0This was really great, although a little too long for a recorded listening
  • shea nowicki -1I liked this song, but had downvote something I'm sorry : ( didn't feel the energy of a live performance for whatever reason