fionmul0 — I like this read. I have never read these lyrics before; wow.
Well done, Sammy. I'm p sure I have never not voted for an LotR submission; it is just such an all-time soundtrack. However, it was displaced from my podium by a couple of songs that matched the aesthetic better which I suppose I decided was a priority for me, clever as this may have been.
Peter Seeley0 — Anything sung in persona Gollum must be sung by a whiny teenage boy. Having it sung by a skilled woman just doesn't work.
Claire0 — Maybe this is a heretical take but I don’t actually like this song very much. And it’s almost too genuinely despairing to fit the theme imo