Sad Boy Summer

League 2 (May 2025) · For the sensitive white boy in all of us

Open playlist on Spotify →

SongArtistSubmitted byVotes
Let Her CryHootie & The Blowfishared56
6
  • SamRobertsND +3 — Best song in this garbage dump of a round and it’s not even close. Darius alone is top tier Sammybait, but in composition and tone this song works too well.
  • Sam Ary +1
  • Regina Scime +1 — It’s Hootie & The Blowfish, I have to
  • Edward James +1 — Yep yep yep Darius knows what’s up. I always wonder what the Blowfish are up to these days
  • fionmul 0 — I wish I had more votes this round bro
  • judd.baker 0 — This was a good Alexcore interpretation of the category. I like it
  • Claire 0 — Classic. But I think the girl might be sadder than the guy in this song
Casimir Pulaski DaySufjan StevensSam Ary
4

Sam Ary: Boohoo

  • Joseph Harvey +3 — Nothing else here made me feel the slightest thing. This produced tears
  • Regina Scime +2
  • judd.baker +1 — Absolutely no notes. Went with the obvious choice and you will be rewarded for it
  • Claire +1 — No boy has ever been sadder than Sufjan. Impossible not to upvote
  • fionmul 0 — 😿
  • Edward James 0 — A GOAT, one of the best to ever do it. But even though Sufjan is certified Sad Boi™, this song is not the one I would choose and I’m going to be honest I can’t articulate why.
  • ared56 -1
  • [DELETED] -1
  • SamRobertsND -1 — Sufjan rose from rags to riches by embodying the emotivism and sensitivity that women narcissistically wish men had. However a fruit with a banjo does not sad boy summer make.
I'm So Lonesome I Could CryHank WilliamsSamRobertsND
4
  • [DELETED] +3
  • ared56 +1
  • Sam Ary +1
  • fionmul 0 — Lonesome fella and sad boy are different to me
  • judd.baker 0 — I like the interpretation of the theme but it’s a stacked round, I’m sorry
  • Edward James 0 — Correct, and an all time great song. But you have to properly interpret the zeitgeist, and this does not reflect such study
  • Claire -1 — The cowboy has chosen a lonesome life. If he’s sad it’s his own damn fault
I Need My GirlThe NationalClaire
3

Claire: Are you really a sad white boy if you don’t listen to the national?

  • fionmul +1 — the background guitar alone was enough for me
  • judd.baker +1 — Perfectly understood the assignment, glad to see the National here
  • ared56 +1
  • Joseph Harvey 0 — I don’t like his voice. I’m sorry he needs his girl but the song didn’t convince me to care
  • Edward James 0 — Just don’t like The National, simple as
  • SamRobertsND 0 — Nice
CornerstoneArctic MonkeysEdward James
2
  • fionmul +1 — I like dis
  • judd.baker +1 — Great song and the ending is part of what does it for me. It doesn’t only end on a pathetic but also a creepy and somewhat fantastical note. Utterly unsympathetic protagonist but does what it’s trying to do well. Dark sad boy summer. Excellent
  • Claire +1 — Quintessential sad boy narrative. Good pick
  • ared56 +1
  • SamRobertsND 0 — Great song.
  • Joseph Harvey -1 — 💤
  • Regina Scime -1
Some Dandruff On Your ShoulderJens Lekmanjudd.baker
1
  • Edward James +2 — A testament to the genre. The line “it’s nothing, it’s nothing” captures more understanding of the male romantic experience than entire artist discographies
  • Claire 0 — This was a cool song but not maximally sad
  • Joseph Harvey 0 — Gross title
  • SamRobertsND 0 — Forgettable
  • fionmul -1 — ew
Let DownRadioheadJoseph Harvey
1

Joseph Harvey: Beautiful aching ennui

  • Sam Ary +1
  • fionmul 0 — a wee bit boring innit
  • judd.baker 0 — Joseph’s submission for this category is also the exact intersection point of our music tastes
  • Claire 0 — Beautiful song. If I had a fourth vote I’d give it to this one
  • Edward James 0 — Don’t like Radiohead, simple as
  • SamRobertsND 0 — The Catholic communists at Hillsdale told me to like Radiohead but idk it never worked
Hold Me While You WaitLewis CapaldiRegina Scime
0
  • fionmul +1 — mmm I am a sucker for Lew sometimes
  • Claire 0 — Could be sadder. At least he has someone to hold him for now…
  • Edward James 0 — Sorry ladies, this is a boys round ^this was the comment I had here for 10 min before I realized this singer is actually a man. Went back and listened to the song again and realized there is no way I could have thought that, and therefore the song must have left so little of an impression that I forgot the gender of the singer. Also, terminal case of zoomer voice.
  • SamRobertsND 0 — AI Generated
  • judd.baker -1 — It’s sad indie pop and yet doesn’t have the true sad boy summer sound. It’s an ephemeral thing. But this is too poppy
WavesDean Lewisfionmul
0
  • Claire +1 — My initial reaction was “this is literally what AI would produce if you told it to write a melancholy white boy pop song.” At first I thought that was a point against the song, but the more I thought about it the more I started to think that this means it deserves a vote for being perfectly on theme
  • fionmul 0 — this ends the first episode of Riverdale and that’s how i found it back in 2018 or something
  • Joseph Harvey 0 — This is decent if generic
  • SamRobertsND 0 — Somehow worse than the other AI song maybe it’s a Lewis thing?
  • Edward James -1 — “You are sheltering an attempt at a hit pop song in your sad boy summer, are you not?”
Change (In the House of Flies)Deftones[DELETED]
-1
  • fionmul 0 — mmm but this song scared my niece
  • Claire 0 — Good song but the prompt was sad boy, not sadistic boy
  • Joseph Harvey 0 — Ok… I can see what this is going for but the execution feels unprofessional to me
  • Edward James 0 — Nah
  • SamRobertsND 0 — Truly terrible, I’m assuming a Corey or Joseph poast?
  • Sam Ary -1